Emily presumed dead later comes back alive creepy and/or rude store clerk Andrew is thrown toward the camera we all enter a vacant or secluded home/building Will is haunted or possessed Killer somehow misses Andrew's obvious hiding spot Amna grabs a blunt kitchen knife Katie trips in the woods, seemingly over nothing power goes out and Trish has to fix it Keli suggests drinking Ryan's car breaks down Kayla has no cell service/ disconnected phone Amber ignores numerous warnings Trish hears something weird but thinks it's nothing Amber and Keli think they're safe but… (there's an open ending) Katie flags down a car that the killer is driving Kayla and Will make an absurdly ineffective barricade creepy/ unsettling children appear Ryan will "be right back" we decide to throw a Halloween party Amna disappears without us realizing Karen decides to go into the basement movement behind Karen without her knowing mirror jumpscare Emily presumed dead later comes back alive creepy and/or rude store clerk Andrew is thrown toward the camera we all enter a vacant or secluded home/building Will is haunted or possessed Killer somehow misses Andrew's obvious hiding spot Amna grabs a blunt kitchen knife Katie trips in the woods, seemingly over nothing power goes out and Trish has to fix it Keli suggests drinking Ryan's car breaks down Kayla has no cell service/ disconnected phone Amber ignores numerous warnings Trish hears something weird but thinks it's nothing Amber and Keli think they're safe but… (there's an open ending) Katie flags down a car that the killer is driving Kayla and Will make an absurdly ineffective barricade creepy/ unsettling children appear Ryan will "be right back" we decide to throw a Halloween party Amna disappears without us realizing Karen decides to go into the basement movement behind Karen without her knowing mirror jumpscare
(Print) Use this randomly generated list as your call list when playing the game. Place some kind of mark (like an X, a checkmark, a dot, tally mark, etc) on each cell as you announce it, to keep track. You can also cut out each item, place them in a bag and pull words from the bag.
I-Emily presumed dead later comes back alive
N-creepy and/or rude store clerk
N-Andrew is thrown toward the camera
O-we all enter a vacant or secluded home/building
B-Will is haunted or possessed
I-Killer somehow misses Andrew's obvious hiding spot
B-Amna grabs a blunt kitchen knife
I-Katie trips in the woods, seemingly over nothing
B-power goes out and Trish has to fix it
O-Keli suggests drinking
N-Ryan's car breaks down
B-Kayla has no cell service/ disconnected phone
G-Amber ignores
numerous warnings
G-Trish hears something weird but thinks it's nothing
G-Amber and Keli think they're safe but…(there's an open ending)
O-Katie flags down a car that the killer is driving
N-Kayla and Will make an absurdly ineffective barricade
B-creepy/ unsettling children appear
O-Ryan will "be right back"
G-we decide to throw a Halloween party
I-Amna disappears without us realizing
I-Karen decides to go into the basement
G-movement behind Karen without her knowing
O-mirror jumpscare