"You saythere'slimited work onX.This is notcorrect.""Useactivevoice""Actually thiswas answeredin [paper thatdoesn't answerthe question]"Insistsyou citereviewer#2's workRecommendationto read a paperyou wroteClearlydidn't readthe paper"Minorchanges"that wouldtake 6months to do"Goodluck!""I lookforward toreading arevisedversion"ObviouspersonalgrudgeAccidentallyrevealstheir ownidentity"Speallingcorrection" tosomethingthat’s wrong"This is animportanttopic,however....""This workis toogeneral"Making upa point toget madat"UseIMRAD"Feedbackcomes aweek late"This workis toospecific""What are theimplications?""Engagewith mycrank pettheory"Demandsquantitativeresults fromqualitativestudy"Usepassivevoice""This would beimproved by[thing thatwould require 6months extrawork]""You wroteabout X, youshould'vewritten aboutY instead""You saythere'slimited work onX.This is notcorrect.""Useactivevoice""Actually thiswas answeredin [paper thatdoesn't answerthe question]"Insistsyou citereviewer#2's workRecommendationto read a paperyou wroteClearlydidn't readthe paper"Minorchanges"that wouldtake 6months to do"Goodluck!""I lookforward toreading arevisedversion"ObviouspersonalgrudgeAccidentallyrevealstheir ownidentity"Speallingcorrection" tosomethingthat’s wrong"This is animportanttopic,however....""This workis toogeneral"Making upa point toget madat"UseIMRAD"Feedbackcomes aweek late"This workis toospecific""What are theimplications?""Engagewith mycrank pettheory"Demandsquantitativeresults fromqualitativestudy"Usepassivevoice""This would beimproved by[thing thatwould require 6months extrawork]""You wroteabout X, youshould'vewritten aboutY instead"

Reviewer #2 bingo - Call List

(Print) Use this randomly generated list as your call list when playing the game. There is no need to say the BINGO column name. Place some kind of mark (like an X, a checkmark, a dot, tally mark, etc) on each cell as you announce it, to keep track. You can also cut out each item, place them in a bag and pull words from the bag.


1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
  1. "You say there's limited work on X. This is not correct."
  2. "Use active voice"
  3. "Actually this was answered in [paper that doesn't answer the question]"
  4. Insists you cite reviewer #2's work
  5. Recommendation to read a paper you wrote
  6. Clearly didn't read the paper
  7. "Minor changes" that would take 6 months to do
  8. "Good luck!"
  9. "I look forward to reading a revised version"
  10. Obvious personal grudge
  11. Accidentally reveals their own identity
  12. "Spealling correction" to something that’s wrong
  13. "This is an important topic, however...."
  14. "This work is too general"
  15. Making up a point to get mad at
  16. "Use IMRAD"
  17. Feedback comes a week late
  18. "This work is too specific"
  19. "What are the implications?"
  20. "Engage with my crank pet theory"
  21. Demands quantitative results from qualitative study
  22. "Use passive voice"
  23. "This would be improved by [thing that would require 6 months extra work]"
  24. "You wrote about X, you should've written about Y instead"