False scare (just a cat!) Survivor finds a weapon Flashlight falls Something is under the bed Jump scare! Possession scene Creepy whispering Final girl moment Creepy child Villain get backs up Someone hides in a closet Chase scene Animal senses danger Obvious red herring Someone goes alone when they shouldn't Old photo or newspaper article Creepy Doll Blood splatter Phone call from the killer Unnecessary nudity Police don't believe them Mirror scare Backstory reveal Seance or ouija board False scare (just a cat!) Survivor finds a weapon Flashlight falls Something is under the bed Jump scare! Possession scene Creepy whispering Final girl moment Creepy child Villain get backs up Someone hides in a closet Chase scene Animal senses danger Obvious red herring Someone goes alone when they shouldn't Old photo or newspaper article Creepy Doll Blood splatter Phone call from the killer Unnecessary nudity Police don't believe them Mirror scare Backstory reveal Seance or ouija board
(Print) Use this randomly generated list as your call list when playing the game. Place some kind of mark (like an X, a checkmark, a dot, tally mark, etc) on each cell as you announce it, to keep track. You can also cut out each item, place them in a bag and pull words from the bag.
B-False scare (just a cat!)
G-Survivor finds a weapon
I-Flashlight falls
O-Something is under the bed
B-Jump scare!
B-Possession scene
G-Creepy whispering
N-Final girl moment
N-Creepy child
N-Villain get backs up
N-Someone hides in a closet
I-Chase scene
I-Animal senses danger
G-Obvious red herring
O-Someone goes alone when they shouldn't
I-Old photo or newspaper article
B-Creepy Doll
O-Blood splatter
G-Phone call from the killer
O-Unnecessary nudity
O-Police don't believe them
I-Mirror scare
G-Backstory reveal
B-Seance or ouija board