Creepy Child Someone hides in a closet Something is under the bed Someone goes alone when they shouldn't Final girl moment Jump scare! Survivor finds a weapon Chase scene Creepy Whispering Animal senses danger Villain gets back up Flashlight falls False scare (just a cat!) Phone call from the killer Blood splatter Rainstorm or thunder Police won't believe them Seance or ouija board Creepy Doll Old photo or newspaper article Obvious red herring Backstory revealed Unnecessary nudity Mirror Scare Creepy Child Someone hides in a closet Something is under the bed Someone goes alone when they shouldn't Final girl moment Jump scare! Survivor finds a weapon Chase scene Creepy Whispering Animal senses danger Villain gets back up Flashlight falls False scare (just a cat!) Phone call from the killer Blood splatter Rainstorm or thunder Police won't believe them Seance or ouija board Creepy Doll Old photo or newspaper article Obvious red herring Backstory revealed Unnecessary nudity Mirror Scare
(Print) Use this randomly generated list as your call list when playing the game. Place some kind of mark (like an X, a checkmark, a dot, tally mark, etc) on each cell as you announce it, to keep track. You can also cut out each item, place them in a bag and pull words from the bag.
I-Creepy Child
I-Someone hides in a closet
O-Something is under the bed
G-Someone goes alone when they shouldn't
B-Final girl moment
O-Jump scare!
I-Survivor finds a weapon
N-Chase scene
N-Creepy Whispering
G-Animal senses danger
O-Villain gets back up
I-Flashlight falls
B-False scare (just a cat!)
G-Phone call from the killer
O-Blood splatter
B-Rainstorm or thunder
G-Police won't believe them
B-Seance or ouija board
I-Creepy Doll
N-Old photo or newspaper article
G-Obvious red herring
O-Backstory revealed
N-Unnecessary nudity
B-Mirror Scare