Scary Story Starters - Call List

(Print) Use this randomly generated list as your call list when playing the game. There is no need to say the BINGO column name. Place some kind of mark (like an X, a checkmark, a dot, tally mark, etc) on each cell as you announce it, to keep track. You can also cut out each item, place them in a bag and pull words from the bag.

1. I was petting my cat when it whispered, “That’s not me”... 🐈💬
2. I was brushing my hair when a second hand grabbed the brush... 💇‍♀️🖐️
3. I was drawing a monster when it started moving... 🎨👹
4. I was chasing my dog when he ran into a mirror and disappeared... 🐶🪞
5. I was putting on my socks when something inside wiggled... 🧦😱
6. I was eating cereal when the spoon floated into the air... 🥣✨
7. I was closing my closet when something whispered, “Wait”... 🚪😬
8. I was watering the plants when one of them said “Ow!”... 🌿😧
9. I was feeding the fish when they spelled a message in the tank... 🐟🔤
10. I was riding my bike when I saw my reflection zoom past me... 🚴🪞
11. I was reading a book when a hand came out of the page... 📖🖐️
12. I was reading a scary story when the door slowly creaked open... 📖🚪
13. I was counting stars when one of them blinked at me... 🌟👁️
14. I was reading under my blanket when something tapped my foot... 📚👣
15. I was packing my backpack when something crawled out of it... 🎒🕷️
16. One day, I was brushing my teeth when the mirror blinked... 🪞🦷
17. I was tying my shoes when one of them hissed at me... 👟🐍
18. I was opening my lunchbox when it shouted “Not again!”... 🍱😲
19. I was taking a bath when the water started laughing... 🛁😳
20. I was sleeping peacefully when someone whispered in my ear... 😴👂
21. I was sharpening a pencil when I found red marks inside... ✏️😨
22. I was picking up leaves outside when one bit me... 🍁🦷
23. I was building a LEGO house when I heard knocking from inside... 🧱🚪
24. I was walking home when I heard footsteps behind me, but no one was there... 👣🌫️
25. One night, I was playing video games when the game said my name... 🎮👀
26. I was watching TV when the character looked at me and waved... 📺👋
27. I was opening a drawer when a cold wind whooshed out... 🧊🌀
28. I was looking under the couch for my toy when something looked back... 🛋️👁️
29. I was baking cookies when they started singing... 🍪🎶
30. I was eating lunch at school when my sandwich growled at me... 🥪😨
31. I was looking out the window when someone identical to me waved... 🪟🧍‍♂️
32. I was doing my homework when my pencil started writing on its own... ✏️📄
33. I was cleaning my room when a voice said, “Don’t move”... 🧹🗣️
34. I was practicing piano when the keys started playing by themselves... 🎹👻